I guess most SF-fans know that Joe Haldeman was a Vietnam veteran with a Purple Heart, and that The Forever War actually is about the Vietnam war – it is even considered a critique of that war in the introduction Haldeman recollects having a hard time getting it published because of that. More on that later, also in the comments. Moreover, its ethics are pathetically superficial: a pretty spectacular fail, especially for an indicting war novel. It works as an allegory, but not as a story. It is not without merit, there’s excellent parts, but overall there’s not enough meat on the bone. I never felt it being a very good book, and I think it never has been. It’s not that the book hasn’t aged well: it hasn’t, but that’s not its problem. 3 different quotes on my edition rave in one way or the other about the book being up there with the big boys of non-genre, non-pulp literature: “the most important war novel written since Vietnam”. Not only a SF-classic, but even a straight out American classic of literature. The Forever War is generally thought of as a SF-classic with everlasting appeal.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |